Skip to main content
A rubric is the scorecard Coach uses to grade a call. You list the things you want your team to do on a call, give each one a point value, and Coach grades every call against the list. Those grades feed each call’s score, the Average Score on your Overview, and the failed-item reports. You build rubrics in Coach → Settings → Rubrics.

Create a rubric

A new rubric is turned on (Active) from the start. As soon as you select Save changes, Coach can use it to grade new calls. If you aren’t ready, turn Active off in the editor before you save.
1

Start a new rubric

Open Coach → Settings → Rubrics and select New rubric. Choose Create inbound rubric or Create outbound rubric, or pick a starting template: Bookable Inbound, Not Bookable Inbound, Bookable Outbound or Not Bookable Outbound.
Coach Rubrics settings with active rubrics and a New rubric button

Rubrics settings lists each rubric with its selection criteria, direction, on/off switch and Edit button.

2

Name it and set the direction

Type a title at the top of the editor. Use the Inbound or Outbound tag next to it to change the direction. A rubric only grades calls that match its direction.
3

Say when it should be used

In Selection criteria, describe the calls this rubric is for, like the type of call, the service, or who took it. Coach reads this to decide which rubric fits a call.
4

Add sections and criteria

Select Add section to group related behaviors, like “Greeting” or “Booking the job.” In each section, select Add criterion and describe one thing the agent should do. Give each criterion points in the Pts box.
5

Check the total

The editor shows the total points across the whole rubric, like Total 100%. The number turns amber when it isn’t 100. A total of 100 makes each criterion easy to read as a share of the score, but it isn’t required.
6

Save

Select Done to close the editor, then select Save changes at the bottom of the page. Done doesn’t save on its own. If you leave the page with unsaved changes, Coach asks you to confirm.

Test it

You can try a saved rubric on real past calls before you rely on it.
  1. Select Test rubric at the top of the Rubrics page.
  2. Pick calls.
  3. Coach grades them and shows you the scores.
Nothing is saved. See “Test a rubric on past calls” below.

More options

Coach answers each criterion with Yes, No or N/A, and writes a short reason.
  • Describe one thing you can see or hear. “Confirmed the service address” works. “Was professional” doesn’t.
  • Say what the agent should do, and add the condition if it matters.
  • Don’t pack several asks into one criterion. It’s harder to grade and harder to coach.
  • Put exceptions in the selection criteria, or in a separate rubric.
Each call’s score is the points from criteria answered Yes, divided by the total points, as a percentage rounded to a whole number. A criterion with more points moves the score more.A criterion answered N/A counts as a Yes, so it doesn’t pull the score down. If every criterion on a call is N/A, the call gets no score and isn’t counted in your averages.Calls with no recording or transcript, and calls with no real conversation such as a voicemail, aren’t graded.
Add a separate rubric when the right behavior is really different, like inbound booking calls and outbound follow-up calls.
  • Coach only considers rubrics that are Active and match the call’s direction.
  • If one active rubric matches the direction, Coach uses it for those calls.
  • If several match, Coach picks the closest fit from the selection criteria. Give each one clearly different selection criteria so Coach doesn’t have to guess.
  • To keep a rubric for certain people, name the agent or agent group in its selection criteria. Agent groups are under Coach → Settings → Agent Groups.
Don’t add a rubric just to get fewer N/A answers. First check that the calls really are a different kind of call.
Select Test rubric. You’ll go through three steps: Calls, Rubric, Results.Calls. Choose how to pick them:
  • Filter calls: pick calls with filters. See the steps below.
  • Enter call IDs: paste up to 25 Coach call IDs.
To use Filter calls:
  1. Pick a date range (up to a year) and any Coach call filters.
  2. Under Pick, choose Random, Lowest score or Most recent.
  3. Under Calls, choose 5, 10 or 25.
  4. Select Get calls.
Lowest score is a quick way to find calls a rubric grades too harshly.Coach tells you how many calls match and how many can be graded. A call needs both a transcript and a ServiceTitan call record to be graded.Rubric. Choose Auto-select per call to see which rubric Coach would pick for each call, or choose one saved rubric. Select Run test.Results. You see the average score and each call’s score.
  • Open a call to read each criterion’s answer and reason.
  • With Auto-select per call, you also see Why this rubric for each call.
  • Select Open on a call to see its transcript in a new tab.
  • Use the circular arrow to run the test again.
Only saved rubrics show up here. If you changed a rubric, save it first.
Rubrics is part of Coach Settings, so you need the View Coach Settings permission. Test rubric is only shown to team admins. Ask your team admin, or see Invite managers and agents to Coach.
At the bottom of the Rubrics page, open Objection handling playbook and write down how your team should handle objections like price or timing. Coach shows this in call reviews to help spot missed chances to handle an objection.Keep it short, up to date, and written as coaching tips. Select Save changes when you’re done.
On the Overview, find Top Failed Rubric Items and select See all. This opens Rubric Performance.Every rubric item is grouped by its section. Open an item to see:
  • Its Success rate, which is 100% minus the share of calls where the item was missed, and how that changed from the earlier period
  • A Coach Suggestion, with a sample script when there is one
  • Calls with this issue, with View issue to jump to the moment in the call
  • View all calls with this issue
  • A Success rate trend over time
Use Filters to limit the page to inbound or outbound calls. If you have more than one rubric, you can also filter to a single rubric. Check the date range before you compare sections.
Open an agent from Agent Performance. In Coaching Insights, select View score breakdowns by all categories. It shows the same sections and items for just that agent’s calls. Use the export button on that page to download it as a PDF.See Compare agents and find who needs coaching.
Open the call and go to its Coaching tab, then find Rubric Grading.
  1. Switch from Locked to Unlocked.
  2. Change the answers that are wrong. You can also edit the reason.
  3. Select Save.
If the rubric doesn’t apply to the call at all, use the circle-with-a-line icon (Exclude from grading) and confirm with Exclude from Grading. This sets every criterion to N/A, so the call has no score and drops out of your averages. You can undo it by editing the answers again.You need the Edit Call Scores permission to change a grade. See Review a Coach call.If the same criterion keeps getting changed by hand, edit the rubric instead.
Use the switch on a rubric’s card to turn it off. Coach stops using it on new calls.Delete rubric in the editor removes it right away, and can’t be undone. If you’re not sure, turn it off instead.
Changing criteria or points changes what a good score means. Coach uses the rubric as it’s saved the next time it grades a call. Note the day you made a big change, and be careful when you compare scores from before and after it.
Check these:
  • At least one rubric is Active and matches the call’s direction.
  • The call has a recording and a transcript, and has finished processing.
  • The call had a real conversation. Voicemails and silent calls aren’t graded.
Open the call’s Coaching tab and read the rubric name and the reason Coach gave for choosing it. Then make the selection criteria of your rubrics more different from each other. A line like “Do not use for billing-only calls” can help.
Check that the right rubric was chosen. If some criteria really don’t apply to a whole kind of call, move them to a rubric for that kind of call.